Bell’s Diarrhoea –
Author & Full Name
- Author: Dr. James B. Bell
- Full Name of Repertory: The Homoeopathic Therapeutics of Diarrhoea, Dysentery, Cholera, Cholera Morbus, Cholera Infantum & all other loose evacuations of the bowels.
Introduction & Editions
- Basic Structure: Contains 3 parts
- Part I – The remedies & their indications
- Part II – Repertory
- Part III – Therapeutics
- Editions
-
1st edition (1869) – Based on 10 years of practical experience of authors. – Printed with the help of Dr. H. N. Guernsey.
-
2nd edition (1881) – Edited by Dr. T. C. Lord who talked of 4 losses of medicines:
- Thoroughly proved & repeatedly verified
- Well proved but lack of clinical confirmation
- Possess only fragmentary & imperfect pathogenesis
-
3rd edition (1888) – Many more derived surely indications. – Many 1st & new remedies were added.
-
4th edition (1896) – The medicines whose indications had been omitted or of less importance have been omitted (e.g., Cactus, Laphamia, Collins, etc.). – Medicines that have been added: Urtica acid, Crotalus, Angustura, Carbolic acid & Valeriana.
Plan & Construction
- Book divided into 2 main Parts Part I – Each remedy is described under: – Stool – Agg – Amel – Before stool – During stool – After stool – Concurrent symptoms
Part II – – Pathological causes – Character of stools – Conditions of stools & accompanying symptoms – Agg – Amel – General accompaniment
-
Typograph (Grading) – Bold (Italics) – 4 marks – Italics – 3 marks – Roman – 2 marks – (Roman) – 1 mark
-
No. of remedies in repertory – 141
Scope
- The repertory is a complete work as it mentions both symptoms of bowel + general state of patient.
- Accompanying symptoms before, during & after are well elaborated.
- Many easy for reference work.
- Pathological causes are guidelines according to the book.
- Helps in meeting GI complaints for children.
Limitations
- Very less no. of remedies are mentioned.
- Relationship of remedies is given at only few places.
- Newly proved remedies were not added.
- Stools has not included medicines whose proving is indefinite.
Additional Keypoints Added for Completeness
- Bell’s Diarrhoea is a concise clinical repertory focused exclusively on bowel complaints, making it quick for bedside use in acute diarrhoeal diseases.
- Strong emphasis on concomitant symptoms and modalities helps in precise differentiation in gastrointestinal cases.
- Though limited in remedy count, it remains valuable for classical indications derived from clinical experience rather than just provings.